What Is Air Gapping?
Air gapping is a security measure that involves isolating a computer or network from other systems and networks, particularly those connected to the Internet. This isolation prevents direct data transfer between the isolated system and external networks, significantly reducing the risk of cyberattacks.
An air-gapped system is physically or logically separated from unsecured networks, with the goal of ensuring sensitive data remains secure and inaccessible to unauthorized users. However, air-gapped systems have their limitations and are not bulletproof. We’ll discuss some of these limitations and alternative approaches.
This is part of a series of articles about data security
Why Is Air Gapping Important in Cybersecurity?
Air-gapped networks aid in protecting highly sensitive information and critical infrastructure from cyber threats. Because these networks are not connected to the Internet, they are less susceptible to remote hacking attempts, malware, and other online threats.
Air gapping systems are suitable for use in environments with strict data integrity and security requirements, such as government agencies, military installations, financial institutions, and industrial control systems. By minimizing the attack surface, air-gapped networks provide a strong defense against cyber espionage, data breaches, and ransomware attacks.
This isolation is especially important in sectors where the compromise of data could have severe consequences, such as national security, finance, healthcare, and critical infrastructure. Additionally, air gaps help in compliance with regulatory requirements that mandate strict data protection measures, helping protect regulated organizations and agencies against legal and financial penalties.
Types of Air Gaps
Air gapping can involve physical or logical techniques.
Physical Air Gap
A physical air gap involves the complete disconnection of a system or network from all external connections, including the Internet, local area networks (LANs), and wireless connections. This means there is no direct or indirect link to other networks, ensuring absolute isolation. Data transfer to and from a physically air-gapped system typically occurs through removable media such as USB drives, CDs, or DVDs, which are manually transported.
While this method provides the highest level of security by preventing remote access and minimizing the risk of cyberattacks, it can be cumbersome and slow for data exchange. It also requires rigorous procedures to prevent the introduction of malware through removable media.
Logical Air Gap
A logical air gap, although not physically disconnected, relies on strict network segmentation and isolation principles to create a virtual separation between secure and unsecured environments.
This separation is achieved using network technologies like firewalls, VLANs (Virtual Local Area Networks), and access control mechanisms. In a logically air-gapped environment, sensitive data and critical systems are protected by layers of security protocols that restrict unauthorized access and monitor data flow.
While not as impervious as a physical air gap, a logical air gap offers a balance between security and operational efficiency, allowing some level of controlled data transfer through secure, encrypted channels and stringent access controls. This approach is particularly useful in environments where complete physical isolation is impractical but high security is still necessary.
Hybrid Air Gap
In a hybrid approach, critical systems may be physically isolated from external networks but connected to other secure systems through controlled and monitored interfaces. This setup allows for essential communication and data sharing within a secure perimeter while maintaining high protection levels against external threats.
For example, an organization might use a physical air gap to separate its most sensitive systems from the Internet while using logical segmentation within the internal network to manage access to less sensitive systems. This ensures that while sensitive data is protected from direct external threats, the operational needs of the organization are still met.
The Criticisms and Limitations of Air Gaps
While air-gapped systems offer a high level of security, they are not without criticisms and limitations:
- Impracticality for frequent data exchange: The manual transfer of data using removable media can be inconvenient and prone to human error. This process slows down operations and introduces the risk of malware if the devices are not properly scanned and secured.
- Expensive maintenance: The need for dedicated hardware, secure facilities, and specialized procedures can result in significant financial and operational overhead. This makes air gaps less feasible for smaller organizations with limited resources.
- Vulnerability to sophisticated attacks: Advanced persistent threats (APTs) and insider threats can exploit physical access points or introduce malware, even if they are air-gapped, through compromised removable media. There have been documented cases where air-gapped systems were breached using methods like electromagnetic waves or acoustic signals to transmit data covertly.
- Difficulty of updating: The isolation inherent to air-gapped systems can hinder the timely application of software updates and patches. This delay can leave systems vulnerable to exploits that have already been mitigated in connected environments.
Alternatives to Air Gapping
Due to the limitations of air gapping, many organizations use alternative approaches:
- Zero Trust architecture: Implementing a zero trust model requires continuous verification of user identity and device integrity. Access is granted based on the principle of least privilege, ensuring users have only the necessary permissions to perform their tasks.
- Defense in depth: Defense in depth is a layered security strategy that involves implementing multiple protective measures at various levels within an organization’s IT infrastructure. Each layer serves as a barrier, ensuring that if one defense fails, others are still in place to protect critical systems and data.
- Data encryption: Encrypting sensitive data at rest and in transit ensures that even if data is intercepted or accessed without authorization, it remains unreadable and secure.
- Endpoint security: Deploying comprehensive endpoint protection solutions, such as antivirus, intrusion detection systems, and application whitelisting, to prevent malware infections and unauthorized access on individual devices.
How to Improve Protection for an Air-Gapped Environment
If you do choose to take the air-gapping approach, here are several measures you can take to better defend an air-gapped environment.
Implement Multi-Factor Authentication
Multi-factor authentication (MFA) adds an extra layer of security by requiring users to provide multiple forms of verification before gaining access to the air-gapped system. This typically involves something the user knows (a password), something the user has (a smart card or mobile device), and something the user is (biometric verification).
By ensuring that only authorized personnel can access critical systems, MFA significantly reduces the risk of unauthorized access and insider threats. Implementing MFA can also deter potential attackers by adding complexity to the authentication process, making it harder to compromise user credentials.
Implement Network Segmentation
Even within an air-gapped environment, it can be useful to divide the network into isolated segments, allowing admins to control and restrict access to sensitive areas. This limits the potential impact of a breach, as attackers would be contained within a single segment and unable to move laterally across the entire network.
Proper segmentation, combined with stringent access controls, enhances the security posture of air-gapped environments. Implementing firewalls, VLANs (Virtual Local Area Networks), and strict access control lists (ACLs) can further compartmentalize and protect different parts of the network, ensuring that only necessary communication paths are open.
Ensure Secure Data Transfer
Data transfers in air-gapped environments must be conducted with caution to prevent the introduction of malware. Use encrypted and authenticated removable media, and ensure that all media are scanned for malware before and after data transfer. Implement strict procedures for handling and transporting data to minimize the risk of human error and unauthorized access.
Where possible, use hardware-based security solutions, such as data diodes, which allow unidirectional data flow, to ensure secure data transfer without physical connectivity. Establish protocols for the secure disposal of outdated or compromised media to prevent unauthorized data retrieval.
Additionally, consider the use of cryptographic signatures to verify the integrity and authenticity of transferred data. This ensures that the data has not been tampered with during transit. Regularly update and review data transfer policies to adapt to new threats and technologies.
Implement Endpoint Protection
Endpoints within an air-gapped environment must be secured with comprehensive endpoint protection solutions. This includes antivirus software, intrusion detection systems (IDS), and endpoint detection and response (EDR) tools. Regularly update and patch all software to mitigate vulnerabilities.
Additionally, implement application allowlisting to ensure that only approved applications can run on the system, reducing the risk of malware infections. Host-based intrusion prevention systems (HIPS) can provide an additional layer of defense by monitoring and blocking suspicious activities on endpoints.
Ensure that all endpoint devices are configured with the least privilege principle, granting users and applications only the permissions they need to perform their tasks. Regularly audit endpoint configurations to identify and remediate any deviations from security policies.
Ensure Monitoring and Auditing
Continuous monitoring and regular auditing are crucial for maintaining the security of an air-gapped environment. Implement logging mechanisms to track all activities and access attempts. Use security information and event management (SIEM) systems to analyze logs in real-time and detect potential security incidents.
Conduct periodic audits to ensure compliance with security policies and identify any gaps in the security posture. Regularly review and update security protocols to address emerging threats and vulnerabilities.
Establish a dedicated incident response team to handle security incidents quickly. Regularly conduct training and simulations to ensure that the team is prepared to respond to various scenarios. Build an incident response plan outlining the steps to take in the event of a security breach, including communication strategies, containment measures, and recovery procedures.
Securing Critical Environments with Imperva
Imperva Data Security Fabric protects all data workloads in hybrid multicloud environments with a modern and simplified approach to security and compliance automation. Imperva DSF flexible architecture supports a wide range of data repositories and clouds, ensuring security controls and policies are applied consistently everywhere.
